Monorepo Tips and Tricks

I've been noodling on monorepos for a while now, and I wasn't sure how I wanted to start sharing some of my thoughts on managing monorepos and making it easier to work within them.

For context, I helped setup and manage a large scale web monorepo while I was at Wayfair, and I've done the same at Fireworks as well. While I don't claim to know everything about monorepos, I have a number of years working within them with a large number of contributors (and 100's of contributions to the main branch per week on average).

This post (and future posts about monorepos), focuses in on "node monorepos", e.g. those that use package managers like npm, bun, yarn, pnpm, deno, etc and where the code uses JavaScript/TypeScript, or otherwise usually relies on node_modules. However some of these recommendations may apply to other kinds of monorepos as well.

I plan to write a bit more about monorepos in the future, but I figured I should start with some top of mind tips and tricks (really just a set of recommendations). These are presented in no particular order - if you have any questions on these feel free to reach out!

Dependency Management

1. Always specify dependencies within the workspace that depend on them

Often when working within a monorepo - some dependencies may have been resolved by other workspaces within the repo. For example, if you have a React application and several libraries used within that application, the react dependency is most likely installed by either the app or the libraries. This can make it really easy to accidentally forget to properly declare a dependency within a new workspace.

Your tests, or other flows may "just work", however you've created an implicit contract that could break depending on how your package manager resolves dependencies, or if you remove that dependency from other workspaces.

The same applies for in-monorepo dependencies, e.g. if you have a workspace that depends on another workspace within the repo - you should specify that as a dependency as well, usually following the format of "workspace-pkg": "workspace:*" which roughly means resolve the workspace-pkg dependency from the local workspaces at any version. See below for managing versions of workspace dependencies!

2. In-repo dependencies must always be one way

Circular dependencies should always be avoided - even if you're not working within a monorepo you want to avoid introducing circular dependencies because they could lead to undefined behavior at run time, or just generally introduce confusion for contributors.

If you have some code in pkg-a (which depends on pkg-b), that pkg-b would like to use - you should extract that code to a shared library that both can depend on (or copy it into both libraries).

3. Workspaces should build themselves

This one is a bit of a 🌶 spicy take 🌶, however I strongly believe that workspaces should have their own build steps, and other workspaces depending on those packages should consume the built artifacts.

This one is particularly important when working with TypeScript, TypeScript doesn't usually understand package boundaries and will continue type checking down through code within dependencies. Not only does this mean that TS will do more work than is necessary - it can sometimes also lead to weird race conditions or generate definition files within the source directory^[1].

The only solid way I've found to avoid this pitfall is two changes:

• Configure skipLibCheck within tsc, and
• Build libraries to some kind of dist directory

On Versioning

There's a number of thoughts I have on versioning within monorepos.

1. Pin External Dependencies

First and foremost - you should always pin external dependencies to a specific version. The only case where you shouldn't pin a dependency, is when you're publishing a package to an external registry (e.g. npm or jsr), and that dependency is a peerDependency.

2. Always point to the latest version of local dependencies

I don't recommend using versioning for internal dependencies, for example if you have two packages in your repo pkg-a and pkg-b, and a depends on b, you don't need to specify a version for b within a's package.json. You can instead use workspace:* to depend on any version of the package, which should resolve the "current version" of that dependency within the repo. This would look like the following package.json:

1{
2  "name": "pkg-a",
3  "dependencies": {
4    "pkg-b": "workspace:*"
5  }
6}

1{
2  "name": "pkg-a",
3  "dependencies": {
4    "pkg-b": "workspace:*"
5  }
6}

3. Adopt a one version rule

This is something I become familiar with while at Wayfair, and have since tried to get others to adopt it as well. The concept comes from a paper by engineers at Google, and boils down to:

For every dependency in [a] repository, there must be only one version of that dependency to choose.

(originally from the book Software Engineering at Google)

I've published the one-version npm package to help enforce this constraint across monorepos with any package manager.

The gist here is to avoid weird edge cases where some dependencies may resolve to different versions - this has been known to cause issues with popular packages like React.

While this may make it difficult to tackle version upgrades on larger monorepos - the consistency afforded by using a single version for each dependency makes this worthwhile.

Footnotes: